Updated 2026-02-14 — Step-by-step cancellation guide
Difficulty
Medium
Avg. Price
$150/mo
Medium — May require extra steps
Opens American Family Insurance's account settings in a new tab.
Option 1: phone(Recommended)
Call 1-800-692-6326 to cancel your American Family Insurance policy. Have your policy number ready. They'll process the cancellation and send written confirmation.
Option 2: online
Log in to amfam.com and contact your local agent to initiate cancellation. Many policies require contacting your assigned agent.
American Family Insurance: auto, home, life, business. IMPORTANT: Have replacement coverage in place BEFORE canceling — a gap in auto/home insurance is illegal in most states and leaves you exposed. Request a refund for any prepaid premium. Get cancellation confirmation in writing. If mid-term, you may receive a pro-rated refund.
American Family Insurance alone is $1800/year. But the average person has 12 active subscriptions — and most don't realize half of them are still charging.
Drop a bank statement and we'll instantly find every recurring charge — with direct cancel links for each one.
Find All My Subscriptions — Free PreviewUpload a CSV or PDF · See your charges free · Pay $5 only to unlock full details
People who cancel American Family Insurance save an average of $182/mo on subscriptions
Upload your bank statement and we'll find every recurring charge in 30 seconds. Most people find 3-5 subscriptions they forgot about.
Scan My Statement — It's FreeNo account needed · No bank connection · 1,000+ people have used JustCancel