How to Cancel Venmo in 2026 (Close Account + Withdraw All Money Safely)
Updated 2026-02-20 ยท 6 min read
๐ฐ Your Money Isn't FDIC Insured (Unless You Opt In)
Money sitting in your Venmo balance is NOT FDIC insured by default. If Venmo (PayPal) goes bankrupt, you could lose it. You must manually enable "FDIC insurance eligibility" in settings. Meanwhile, Venmo charges 1.75% for instant transfers, 3% for credit card sends, and their "Pay in 4" BNPL creates installment debt. Zelle does the same core function for free.
Venmo's Hidden Costs
Instant transfer: 1.75% fee (min $0.25, max $25) โ vs free 1-3 day standard transfer
Credit card send: 3% fee โ use debit or bank instead
Venmo Credit Card: Up to 3% cashback but 27.24% APR if you carry a balance
Venmo Debit Card: $2.50 out-of-network ATM fee
Pay in 4: BNPL through PayPal โ late fees and credit reporting
Crypto: 1.8-2.3% spread on Bitcoin/Ethereum purchases
Business transactions: 1.9% + $0.10 per transaction for sellers
Before Closing: Withdraw Everything
Check your balance: Open Venmo โ tap your balance at the top
Transfer to bank: Tap Transfer to Bank โ enter full amount โ choose Standard (free)
Sell crypto: If you hold Bitcoin/Ethereum, sell it and transfer proceeds to bank
Wait for pending: Any incoming payments or bank transfers must clear first (1-3 days)
Check for subscriptions: Merchants may charge your Venmo account โ check Profile โ Settings โ Automatic Payments
How to Close Your Venmo Account
Ensure balance is $0.00 (no pending transactions)
Open Venmo app โ tap โฐ menu (top left) โ Settings
Scroll to bottom โ Close Venmo Account
Follow the prompts โ Venmo will try to retain you
Confirm closure
Note: This does NOT close your PayPal account โ Venmo is a subsidiary of PayPal but they're separate accounts
โ ๏ธ Cancel the Venmo Credit Card Separately
The Venmo Credit Card is issued by Synchrony Bank, not Venmo/PayPal. Closing your Venmo account does NOT cancel the credit card. Call Synchrony at 1-855-878-6462 to close the card separately. Pay off any balance first.
Privacy Concerns
Public by default: Venmo transactions were public by default until 2021 โ researchers scraped 200M+ transactions
Biden's Venmo: In 2021, BuzzFeed found President Biden's Venmo account and his entire friend network in 10 minutes
Social feed: Even after privacy changes, Venmo's social feed shows friends' transactions โ oversharing by design
PayPal data sharing: As a PayPal subsidiary, your Venmo data is subject to PayPal's broad data sharing policies
Before closing: Set all transactions to Private (Settings โ Privacy โ Private)
Delete Your Data
After closing your account, email privacy@venmo.com
Subject: "CCPA Data Deletion Request"
Request deletion of all personal data, transaction history, and social graph data
They must respond within 45 days
Download your data first: Settings โ Privacy โ Download My Data
Better Alternatives
Zelle: Built into most bank apps, instant, free, FDIC-insured โ no separate app needed
Apple Pay / Google Pay: Send money to contacts, free, integrated into your phone
Your bank's app: Most banks now offer free P2P transfers via Zelle integration
For splitting bills: Splitwise (tracks debts, settles via any method) โ no payment processing fees
๐ก The Payment App Consolidation
Most people have Venmo + Cash App + PayPal + Zelle. That's 4 apps with money scattered across them, 4 security targets, and 4 sets of fees. Consolidate to Zelle (already in your bank app) for P2P payments. One app, zero fees, full FDIC insurance, no social feed sharing your spending habits.
๐ Track All Your Payment App Charges
Venmo, Cash App, and PayPal charges show up on your bank statement under various names. Upload your statement to JustCancel to find every recurring charge across all your payment apps.