How to Cancel Ollie Dog Food 2026 — Fresh Dog Food at $200-400/Month

Updated March 2026 • 6 min read

Ollie is another fresh dog food delivery service competing with The Farmer's Dog, Nom Nom, and JustFoodForDogs. Like its competitors, Ollie uses a guilt-driven marketing model that implies you're a bad pet parent if you feed kibble. The reality: at $200-400+/month for most dogs, you're paying luxury restaurant prices for pet food.

💰 Ollie pricing reality: They advertise "starting at $3/day" but that's for small dogs on their baked recipe (the cheapest option). A 50-lb dog on fresh recipes runs $7-10/day ($210-300/month). Large breeds? $12-15/day ($360-450/month). The 50% first-order discount makes it look affordable — then reality hits on order two.

How to Cancel Ollie

Log into myollie.com
Go to Account Settings
Click Manage Subscription
Select Cancel Subscription (not pause)
They'll offer discounts and free boxes — decline if you want out
Confirm cancellation

If you can't find the cancel option online, email care@myollie.com or call 1-646-883-1679. Ollie's customer service is generally responsive and will process cancellations without excessive pushback.

✅ Tip: Before canceling, check if Ollie offers a "half-fresh" plan where you mix their food with kibble. This can cut costs by 50% while transitioning. But honestly, a fresh food topper from your grocery store (cooked chicken, sweet potato, peas) on quality kibble achieves the same thing for a fraction of the price.

Ollie vs. The Farmer's Dog vs. Nom Nom

All three fresh dog food companies follow the same playbook:

Heavy 50% first-order discount to get you hooked
Emotional marketing — "your dog deserves real food"
Personalization quiz to make it feel custom (it's 4-5 recipes for all dogs)
Auto-ship default that's hard to pause or cancel
$200-400/month ongoing cost that few dog owners sustain long-term

The fresh dog food industry is worth over $2 billion and growing — largely because pet parents feel guilty about kibble. But veterinary nutritionists consistently say that WSAVA-compliant kibble is nutritionally complete and perfectly healthy for the vast majority of dogs.

Better Alternatives for Your Budget

Purina Pro Plan: $50-80/month — the most vet-recommended brand, WSAVA-compliant
Royal Canin: $60-100/month — breed-specific and condition-specific formulas
Hill's Science Diet: $55-90/month — extensive research, prescription options
DIY fresh topper: Add boiled chicken breast, steamed vegetables, or a raw egg to quality kibble — $20-30/month extra
JustFoodForDogs (retail): Buy in-store at Petco — no subscription, choose when you want it

The 10-Day Transition Plan

Switching from fresh food to kibble requires a gradual transition to avoid stomach upset:

Days 1-3: 75% Ollie + 25% new food
Days 4-6: 50% Ollie + 50% new food
Days 7-9: 25% Ollie + 75% new food
Day 10+: 100% new food
Add warm water or low-sodium broth to kibble to increase palatability
If your dog refuses kibble after being on fresh, try adding a fresh food topper

🐕 Reality check: Your dog ate kibble happily before Ollie. They'll adjust back. Dogs care about routine and your attention far more than whether their food was human-grade. The $2,400-4,800/year you save switching to quality kibble can go toward vet visits, training, and actually spending time with your pet.

⚡

Quick Cancel Guide: Ollie Dog Food

Direct cancel link + step-by-step instructions

How to Cancel Ollie Dog Food 2026 — Fresh Dog Food at $200-400/Month