How to Cancel Nutrisystem in 2026 (Avoid the Auto-Ship Trap)

Updated February 2026 · 5 min read

Nutrisystem costs $300-400/month depending on your plan — making it one of the most expensive subscriptions most people have. The auto-delivery ships every 4 weeks whether you're ready or not. And youcannot cancel online. You must call. Here's exactly how.

🔴 Timing matters: Cancel at least 2 days before your next ship date. Once a shipment processes, you're charged and can't return opened food. Check your ship date in your Nutrisystem account under My Plan → Delivery Schedule.

How to Cancel by Phone (The Only Way)

Call 1-800-585-5483 (Mon-Sun, 8am-11pm EST)
Say "Cancel my auto-delivery"
They'll ask why and offer discounts — use the script below
Confirm cancellation and get a confirmation number
Ask them to send email confirmation

Retention Script (What They'll Say vs. What to Say)

Them: "Can I ask why you're cancelling?"
You: "It's not in my budget right now."

Them: "What if I give you 40% off your next month?"
You: "No thank you, I'd like to cancel today."

Them: "How about we pause your deliveries instead?"
You: "No, I want a full cancellation, not a pause."

Them: "You'll lose your discounted pricing..."
You: "That's fine. Please process the cancellation now."

Can You Return Unopened Food?

Nutrisystem accepts returns of unopened, undamaged food within 30 days of delivery. You'll get a refund minus a $19.99 shipping/restocking fee. Call the same number to initiate a return. They'll email a prepaid return label. Keep the tracking number — refunds take 5-7 business days after they receive the package.

The Real Cost of Nutrisystem

Most people don't realize how much Nutrisystem actually costs per year:

Basic Plan: ~$300/month = $3,600/year
Uniquely Yours: ~$350/month = $4,200/year
Uniquely Yours Ultimate: ~$400/month = $4,800/year
Plus groceries: You still need fresh fruits, vegetables, and dairy — add $200-300/month
True annual cost: $5,400-$7,200 including supplemental groceries

Why Most People Quit (And What to Do Instead)

Research shows most meal delivery diet plans have high dropout rates. Common complaints about Nutrisystem:

Portion sizes are tiny — meals are 200-300 calories each
Food quality is mediocre — heavily processed, shelf-stable meals
Not sustainable — most people regain weight after stopping because they never learned to cook
Way too expensive — you can eat healthier for half the cost by meal prepping

Free & Cheaper Alternatives

MyFitnessPal (free): Calorie tracking alone produces similar weight loss results
Budget meal prep: r/MealPrepSunday — healthy meals for $3-5 each
$5 Meal Plan: Weekly meal plans + grocery lists for $5/month (vs $300+)
Lose It! (free): Simple calorie counter with barcode scanning
Your doctor: Free nutritional counseling is often covered by insurance

💡 Pro tip: Upload your bank statement to JustCancel to see exactly how much you've spent on Nutrisystem and other subscriptions. The total is often shocking.

⚡

Quick Cancel Guide: Nutrisystem Weight Loss

Direct cancel link + step-by-step instructions