Is identity theft protection worth paying for?

For most people, no. A credit freeze at all 3 bureaus (free by law) prevents new accounts from being opened in your name — which is the main form of identity theft. Paid services mostly alert you after fraud happens, while a freeze prevents it from happening at all.

What about the $1 million identity theft insurance?

The '$1M insurance' is mostly marketing. It covers expenses related to restoring your identity (paperwork, legal fees, lost wages) — NOT the fraudulent charges themselves (your bank covers those under federal law). Most claims are under $500. Your homeowners or renters insurance may already include similar coverage.

Cancel IdentityForce / ID Theft Protection (2026 Guide)

IdentityForce, Identity Guard, LifeLock, and others charge $10-30/month for identity "protection." A credit freeze provides better actual protection for $0. Here's how to cancel and set up real security.

⚡ Quick Cancel:
• IdentityForce: Call 1-866-517-5723 or cancel at identityforce.com → Account → Cancel
• Identity Guard: Call 1-855-443-7748
• LifeLock: Call 1-800-543-3562 or cancel at lifelock.com → Settings → Membership

The Identity Theft Protection Industry

This is a $10+ billion/year industry built on fear. Here's what they don't tell you:

Monitoring ≠ protection: These services watch for fraud and alert you. They don't prevent it.
Credit freezes are free and preventative: A freeze actually blocks new accounts from being opened
Federal law protects you: Your maximum liability for credit card fraud is $50 (and most banks waive that). Debit card fraud is $0 if reported within 2 days.
"$1M insurance" is mostly marketing: It covers restoration expenses (averaging under $500 per claim), not the fraudulent charges themselves
Dark web scanning is theater: If your data is on the dark web, there's nothing these services can do about it. The data is already out there.

Price Comparison: Paid vs Free

IdentityForce UltraSecure+Credit: $23.99/month = $288/year
Identity Guard Total: $19.99/month = $240/year
LifeLock Ultimate Plus: $29.99/month = $360/year
Norton 360 + LifeLock: $99-350/year (bundled with antivirus)
Free alternative stack: $0/year with better actual protection

The Free Protection Stack (Better Than Any Paid Service)

Set up once, protected forever — $0:

1. Credit freeze at all 3 bureaus (15 min total):
  • Experian: experian.com/freeze
  • Equifax: equifax.com/personal/credit-report-services/credit-freeze
  • TransUnion: transunion.com/credit-freeze
  • Bonus: Freeze at ChexSystems, LexisNexis, SageStream too

2. Credit Karma alerts — Free monitoring of TransUnion + Equifax changes

3. Bank transaction alerts — Set to $0 threshold (every charge notifies you instantly)

4. Google dark web report — Free with any Google account

5. AnnualCreditReport.com — Free weekly reports from all 3 bureaus

6. IRS Identity Protection PIN — Free, prevents tax fraud (irs.gov/identity-theft-fraud-scams/get-an-identity-protection-pin)

When Paid ID Theft Protection Might Make Sense

You've been a victim of identity theft and need restoration assistance
You don't want to manage credit freezes yourself (legitimate convenience factor)
Your employer offers it for free (don't pay, but use it if included in benefits)
You were part of a data breach that offers free monitoring — use the free period, then cancel

The 5-Year Math

Paid monitoring (5 years): $1,200-1,800
Free freeze + monitoring (5 years): $0
Better protection level: Free (freeze prevents fraud; monitoring just reports it)
Time to set up free stack: 30 minutes, one time

📊 Find All Your Recurring Security Charges
Upload your bank statement to JustCancel — we'll find every subscription including identity protection and antivirus you might not need.

⚡

Quick Cancel Guide: Identityforce

Direct cancel link + step-by-step instructions