How to Cancel Gwynnie Bee (CaaStle) Clothing Rental in 2026
Gwynnie Bee (now operating under CaaStle) costs $49-199/month for clothing rental in sizes 0-32. That's up to $2,388/year. Return ALL items before canceling or you'll be charged full retail.
🔴 Return Items First: You must return every rented garment before canceling. Unreturned items are charged at full retail price ($40-200+ per piece). Use the prepaid shipping label and get tracking confirmation.
Step 1: Return All Items
- Check your account for all items currently checked out
- Pack items in the prepaid return bag
- Drop at USPS or schedule pickup
- Wait for return confirmation (3-5 business days)
- Verify ALL items show as returned in your account
Step 2: Cancel Subscription
- Go to closet.gwynniebee.com and sign in
- Go to "Account" or "Membership"
- Click "Cancel membership"
- If no online option, email help@gwynniebee.com
- Or call 1-855-499-6643
Plans and Pricing
- 1 item at a time: $49/month
- 2 items: $69/month
- 3 items: $95/month
- 5 items: $139/month
- 10 items: $199/month
Alternatives for Plus-Size Fashion
- Nuuly ($98/mo, 6 items) — by Urban Outfitters, sizes XS-XL (some brands to 3X)
- ThredUp — secondhand clothing at 50-90% off, wide size range, buy and keep
- Torrid — plus-size specialty (sizes 10-30), frequent sales
- Universal Standard — sizes 00-40, quality investment pieces
- Target (Ava & Viv) — affordable plus-size, sizes 14W-30W
💡 Cost Analysis: Even the cheapest plan ($49/mo = $588/yr) rents you one item at a time. ThredUp averages $10-20 per piece — $588 buys you 30-60 permanent wardrobe additions instead of temporary rentals.
🔍 Not sure what you're paying for? Upload your bank statement to JustCancel — we'll find all your subscriptions and show you how to cancel each one.