How to Cancel Blue Cross Blue Shield in 2026 (All States + Subsidiaries)
BCBS isn't one company — it's 34 independent companies using the same brand. Your cancellation process depends on which state's BCBS you have. Here's the universal guide.
⚡ Key Fact: Blue Cross Blue Shield is a federation of 34 separate companies. Anthem Blue Cross (CA, NY), Highmark (PA, WV), HCSC (IL, TX), CareFirst (MD, DC), and others each have different processes. Find your card — the subsidiary name is printed on it.
Step 1: Identify Your BCBS Subsidiary
Check your insurance card for the exact company name. Major BCBS subsidiaries include:
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield: CA, CO, CT, GA, IN, KY, ME, MO, NH, NV, NY, OH, VA, WI
HCSC (Health Care Service Corp): IL, MT, NM, OK, TX
Highmark: PA, WV, DE
CareFirst: MD, DC, Northern VA
Premera: WA, AK
Blue Cross NC: North Carolina
BCBS of Michigan: Michigan
Independence Blue Cross: Philadelphia area
Florida Blue: Florida
Horizon BCBS: New Jersey
Cancel BCBS Individual Plan
Call the number on your card — this routes to your specific subsidiary
Request cancellation effective at end of current billing period
Ask for written confirmation via email
If enrolled via healthcare.gov, cancel through the marketplace website instead
Cancel BCBS Employer Plan
Contact your HR department — not BCBS directly
You can only cancel during open enrollment or with a Qualifying Life Event
If leaving your job, ask about COBRA continuation
Your employer may have a specific form or portal for coverage changes
Cancel BCBS Medicare Supplement/Advantage
Medicare Advantage (Part C): Cancel during Medicare Open Enrollment (Oct 15 - Dec 7) or Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment (Jan 1 - Mar 31)
Medigap/Supplement: Can cancel anytime, but guaranteed issue rights are limited — you may not get another Medigap plan without medical underwriting
Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) before canceling to understand your options
BCBS Contact Numbers by Major Subsidiary
Anthem: 1-800-331-1476
Florida Blue: 1-800-352-2583
HCSC (IL/TX/OK/NM/MT): 1-800-546-4677
Highmark (PA/WV/DE): 1-800-328-5433
CareFirst (MD/DC): 1-800-544-8703
BCBS of Michigan: 1-800-662-6667
Horizon (NJ): 1-800-355-2583
Blue Cross NC: 1-877-258-3334
Premera (WA/AK): 1-800-722-1471
Or just use the number on your insurance card
Before You Cancel: Essential Checklist
✅ New coverage secured with confirmed start date
✅ All pending claims filed (you usually have 1 year after service date)
✅ Prescription medications verified on new plan's formulary
✅ Doctors confirmed in-network on new plan
✅ Any ongoing treatments (physical therapy, mental health, etc.) will be covered
✅ FSA funds used before plan ends
✅ EOB (Explanation of Benefits) documents saved for all recent claims
Why People Leave BCBS
Network narrowing: BCBS networks have shrunk in many states. Your doctor may no longer be in-network.
Premium increases: Average 8-12% annual premium hikes across BCBS subsidiaries
Better marketplace options: Oscar, Ambetter, and Kaiser often have lower premiums with similar coverage
Prior authorization burden: BCBS is frequently cited for excessive prior auth requirements
💡 Pro Tip: Before switching, check if your BCBS plan has a "narrow network" variant at lower cost. Some BCBS subsidiaries offer Blue Focus or Blue Priority plans at 20-30% less with a smaller but adequate network.
🔍 Find All Your Subscriptions
Health insurance is your biggest recurring bill, but you might have 5-10 other subscriptions adding up. Upload your bank statement to find them all.