How to Cancel BarkBox Super Chewer in 2026
Super Chewer costs $45/month (monthly), $35/month (6-month), or $29/month (12-month). Multi-month plans are prepaid — meaning you paid $210-348 upfront. Here's how to cancel before it renews.
Cancel Online
- Go to barkbox.com/account
- Sign in to your BarkBox account
- Go to "Subscription"
- Click "Cancel subscription"
- They'll offer alternatives — decline if you want to fully cancel
- Confirm cancellation
Cancel by Contact
- Email: happy@barkbox.com
- Phone: 1-855-520-2275
- Chat: Available on barkbox.com (bottom right)
Multi-Month Plan Refunds
⚠️ Important:
- 6-month plan ($210 total): Prepaid, no refund for unused months
- 12-month plan ($348 total): Prepaid, no refund for unused months
- Monthly plan ($45/mo): Cancel anytime, stops at end of billing period
- Canceling mid-plan just prevents auto-renewal — you still get remaining boxes
The Toy Guarantee
💡 Before canceling for toy durability issues: Super Chewer has a "Scout's Honor" guarantee — if your dog destroys a toy within the first 2 weeks of receiving the box, they'll send a free replacement. Contact happy@barkbox.com with a photo of the destroyed toy.
Super Chewer vs Regular BarkBox
- Regular BarkBox ($23-35/mo): Plush toys, treats, chews. For normal chewers
- Super Chewer ($29-45/mo): Rubber/nylon toys, treats, meaty chews. For aggressive chewers
- If your dog is somewhere in between, regular BarkBox might be enough at $10-20 less/month
Cheaper Alternatives
- Buy toys directly — Kong ($10-15), Nylabone ($8-12), and Goughnuts ($15-20) are the most durable chew toys. Buy 2-3 and they'll outlast months of subscription boxes
- Bullymake ($27-39/mo) — similar concept, sometimes tougher toys
- PetSmart/Chewy sales — buy durable toys in bulk during sales events
- Dollar store for treats — the treats in subscription boxes are often available cheaper at pet stores
💡 The Math: Super Chewer monthly plan = $540/year. That buys ~36 high-quality Kong/Nylabone toys ($15 each) plus treats. Most dogs are happy with 3-4 rotating toys. The subscription box novelty wears off (for you and the dog).
🔍 Not sure what you're paying for? Upload your bank statement to JustCancel — we'll find all your subscriptions and show you how to cancel each one.